DF 72: Livestream / Video Recordings

Access to the livestreamlng will be available at the day of the event (payment required, see section "Registration" above).
Videos will be available for free after DF 72 (estimated from September 16, 2019) via this link:  https://video.ethz.ch/events/lca/2019/autumn/72nd.html

DF 72: 72nd LCA Discussion Forum

DF 72 — Normalization and weighting. The forgotten theme in LCA.

Discussion forum on Life Cycle Assessment
Monday, 9 September 2019, ETH Zürich, Alumni (GEP) Pavillon

To draw the right conclusions based on environmental indicators can be a challenging task due to the consideration of a broad variety of environmental impacts that show diverging results. Many LCA practitioners seek help in interpreting diverging results in different impact categories by applying single score LCIA methods. But the ISO standards do not support weighting for publishing comparative LCA. Nevertheless, the increasing need for unequivocal results lead to the development of single score impact assessment method.

This DF focuses on the present state of normalization and weighting in LCA. The statements in ISO 14040 are taken as one of the baselines, e.g. concerning internal and external normalization and hints on interpretation. The ongoing developments for the technical specification on this theme (ISO/TS 14074) are covered. Approaches broadening this view in ISO will be presented as well.

An overview on present schemes such as the ILCD recommendations for LCIA and further developments within the EU Product Environmental Footprint (PEF) initiative will be provided. Another key question will be: How useful is the concept of the carrying capacity or the planetary boundaries for aggregating indicator scores?

A discussion of different weighting methods should shed more light on the uncertainties and differences of various approaches (e.g. transparency, completeness, applicability). The forum should launch further discussion about these issues to initiate also a revision of standards like ISO 14040/44/74 to better reflect the current state of the art.

In summary, the DF aims at a critical discussion and review of currently available methods for normalization and weighting to promote a better understanding of the complex topic and controversial
debate in the scientific community. How ISO standards on weighting, normalization and grouping can be implemented in the future are identified. Research needs are formulated to foster progress in this field of LCA application.

This forum aims to provide a fertile ground for discussion between LCA researchers, practitioners and other people interested in the interpretation and development of normalization and weighting methods.

Programme

Download:    DF72-Programme_Normalization and weighting.pdf 
 

Time Title Speaker Affiliation
8:45  Registration, coffee & croissants    
9:10  Welcome and introduction to the day
DF72-00_Meili.pdf
Christoph Meili  ESU-services 
  Method [Chair: Christoph Meili]   
9:15  Normalization and weighting of sustainability indicators: current status and main challenges
DF72-01_Roesch.pdf
Andreas Roesch  Agroscope 
9:45  Normalization and weighting in ISO standards
DF72-02_Buxmann.pdf
Kurt Buxmann  SNV NK 174 
10:15  Discussion    
10:20  Coffee break    
  Research [Chair: Andreas Roesch]   
10:50  Normalisation and weighting as applied in Product Environmental Footprint
DF72-03_Sala.pdf
Serenella Sala  EC JRC 
11:20  The influence of normalization and weighting on results by different possibilities given in the ISO Standard
DF72-04_Jungbluth.pdf
Niels Jungbluth  ESU-services 
11:50  Discussion    
  Short Presentations [Chair: Andreas Roesch]   
12:00  Does the approach on weighting in the Swiss ecological scarcity method allow a consistent evaluation? Discuss Grouping as an influencing factor
DF72-05_Meili.pdf
Christoph Meili, Niels Jungbluth  ESU-services 
12:10  Comparison of Swiss and European eco-factors
DF72-06_Braunschweig.pdf
Arthur Braunschweig  E2 Management 
12:20  External normalization of LC(S)A resukts for outranking methods in MCDA
DF72-07_Wulf.pdf
Christina Wulf  Jülich Forschungszentrum 
12:30  Questions to all 3 short presentations    
12:40  Lunch    
13:40  Development of normalization and weighting factors for G20 countries
DF72-08_Itsubo.pdf
Norihiro Itsubo (on video)   Tokyo City University 
14:10  Weighting in multi-criteria sustainability assessments: quantifying the uncertainty of expert judgements in the SMART Farm Tool
DF72-09_Curran.pdf
Michael Curran  FiBL 
14:40  Consistent normalization approach for Life Cycle Assessment based on a study-specific reference system
DF72-10_Helias.pdf
Arnaud Hélias  TU Berlin/Irstea 
15:10  Discussion    
15:20  Coffee break    
  Politics [Chair: Niels Jungbluth]   
15:40  Are single score indicators preferable? The use of weighting in the Italian policy initiative «Made Green in Italy».
DF72-11_Zamagni.pdf
Alessandra Zamagni  ecoinnovazione 
16:10  Relevance of a single score approach and planetary boundaries from the Swiss policy perspective
DF72-12_Kaenzig.pdf
Josef Känzig  FOEN (BAFU) 
16:40  Discussion    
  Wrap-up, announcements and farewell [Chair: Niels Jungbluth]   
16:50  Announcement next DF 73 Roland Hischier  EMPA 
16:55  Announcement Special DF 75 Rolf Frischknecht  treeze 
17:00  Wrap up and announcements
DF72-13_Jungbluth.pdf
Niels Jungbluth  ESU-services 
17:05  Farewell    
19 November 2019 Copyright 2012 by LCA Discussion Forum  | Terms Of Use | Privacy Statement